Finding the Right Moment: How UCF Reaches Students Before Problems Pile Up

Jason Fife

January 16, 2026

Watch Now

Finding the Right Moment: How UCF Reaches Students Before Problems Pile Up

How UCF Reaches Students Before Problems Pile Up

At the University of Central Florida, student success didn’t improve because the institution sent more messages.

It improved because UCF got far more precise about when to reach out, who to reach, and what kind of help actually mattered in that moment.

In a recent conversation, Tyler Walsh, Director of the Center for Higher Education Innovation (CHEI), shared how UCF shifted from reactive support to a signal-driven, upstream model—using conversational AI not as a broadcast channel, but as a scalpel.

What follows is not a story about technology adoption.
It’s a story about changing the order of work.

The problem: reactive systems create reactive work

Like many large institutions, UCF already had:

  • Dedicated advisors and support staff

  • Dashboards and reports

  • Emails, portals, and office hours

Yet help often arrived after damage was done:

  • A registration window missed

  • A hold unresolved until it blocked enrollment

  • A gateway course failed before anyone intervened

Support depended on students asking for help, or staff discovering issues once they had already escalated.

As Tyler put it, the challenge wasn’t effort. It was timing.

 

Tyler Walsh explains why UCF chose to develop Knightbot

The shift: from broadcast to precision

UCF’s breakthrough wasn’t replacing human work—it was reordering it.

Instead of asking:

How do we reach more students?

UCF began asking:

Which students are about to hit a barrier—and how much time do we have to intervene?

That reframing changed everything.

Conversational AI became useful not because it automated responses, but because it allowed UCF to:

  • Detect early signals of friction

  • Intervene before deadlines and consequences

  • Reserve human time for students who explicitly needed help

Email still goes to everyone.
Advisors still provide personalized guidance.

But text outreach is used surgically—for the students most likely to stall without timely support.

What “working upstream” looks like in practice

At UCF, working upstream means treating barriers as predictable events, not surprises.

Examples include:

  • Registration holds identified weeks before enrollment opens

  • FAFSA verification requirements known in advance

  • Course performance signals that appear well before failure

These aren’t guesses. They’re data-backed moments.

Instead of waiting for students to ask questions, UCF proactively reaches out with:

  • A relevant message

  • A clear call to action

  • An easy way to raise a hand for help

Tyler Walsh describes the real power of Knightbot’s proactive outreach to students

Signals, not assumptions

A critical insight from UCF’s work is that precision depends on signals, not segmentation stereotypes.

UCF doesn’t decide who needs help based on:

  • Demographics alone

  • Static risk labels

  • Broad outreach rules

Instead, it watches for real behavior and context:

  • Did the student respond to a message?

  • Did they indicate they want help?

  • Are they engaging (or not) when it matters?

Those signals shape:

  • Who gets contacted

  • When outreach happens

  • Which staff step in

This turns outreach into a conversation, not a guess.

Tyler Walsh discusses Knightbot’s ability to send targeted campaigns with relevant information to each learner.

Impact: fewer fires, better outcomes

One of the clearest examples Tyler shared involved registration holds.

By texting students before registration opened:

  • UCF resolved hundreds of holds in advance

  • More students registered on time

  • Engagement rates were significantly higher for students who interacted with the campaign

Students who responded and asked for help registered at substantially higher rates than peers facing the same barrier who did not engage.

The takeaway: early, relevant outreach doesn’t just inform, it changes behavior.

Staff experience: from cold calls to real conversations

The precision model changed staff work just as much as student outcomes.

Before:

  • Long call lists

  • Little context

  • Low response rates

After:

  • Lists of students who asked for help

  • Clear understanding of the issue before outreach

  • Students who expect (and answer) the call

As Tyler described, this isn’t just efficiency. It’s morale.

Tyler Walsh describes the impact of Knightbot’s outreach on staff morale

Ethics and trust: making scale safe

UCF’s approach only works because trust is protected.

From the start, the institution built guardrails:

  • Opt-out messaging to respect student choice

  • Institution-owned, curated knowledge—not free-form answers

  • Clear escalation paths for safety, mental health, housing, and food insecurity

  • Careful, limited piloting of generative AI

Trust isn’t a side benefit—it’s infrastructure.

Tyler Walsh shares the importance of ensuring Knightbot’s messages build trust

The deeper lesson for institutions

UCF’s story isn’t about copying a tool or a campaign.

It’s about:

  • Re-centering work around moments that matter

  • Letting data and conversation signals guide effort

  • Using AI to surface human work, not replace it

  • Designing for your institution’s scale, staffing, and students

As Tyler emphasized, this approach looks different everywhere, and it should.

According to Tyler, the first step leaders should take when considering a similar approach is identifying the problem or issue unique to their own institution.

UCF didn’t win by doing more.

They won by doing earlier, smarter, and more human work, enabled by precision tools that respect trust, staff capacity, and student reality.

That’s what finding the right moment really means.

Ready to meet the moment?

Share on social

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Subscribe for free

Sign up to receive Mainstay's latest insights on AI and Student Success — right in your inbox.

Book a call with us:

Get a guided tour of Mainstay’s Engagement Platform

Mainstay’s Engagement Platform uses Behavioral Intelligence to help businesses build meaningful relationships, optimize insights, and drive action.

Sign up for your personalized demo to find out how Mainstay makes it easy to spark conversations with your employees and guide them toward positive results.

Channels

Instant support — anytime, anywhere

Mainstay’s behaviorally intelligent chatbots make it easy to engage with employees on the channels they prefer to use:

SMS text messaging
Live chat
Web chat
Social media

Let's talk

Get a guided tour of Mainstay’s Engagement Platform

Mainstay’s Engagement Platform uses Behavioral Intelligence to help schools and businesses build meaningful relationships, optimize insights, and drive action.

Sign up for your personalized demo to find out how Mainstay makes it easy to spark conversations with your students or employees and guide them toward positive results.

Channels

Instant support — anytime, anywhere

Mainstay’s behaviorally intelligent chatbots make it easy to engage with students and employees on the channels they prefer to use:

SMS text messaging
Live chat
Web chat
Social media

Let's talk